The chips are down
October 21st, 2008So what do potato chips have to do with the bdsm?
In upstate new york, just before the civil war, a diner at a resort restraunt did something that no customer at any food service establishement should ever do. He pissed off the cook.
I remember back in the days when I was slinging hash for a living we had this once customer that came in every single wensday at exactly 6PM and ordered an extra rare steak. And every time, week after week, he would always send it back to the kitchen saying it was overcooked. Didnt matter how rare we tried to make it, he sent it back to the kitchen just as a matter of pride. Well, one week we in the kitchen got fed up with this, took a RAW steak, grabbed a magic marker and drew grill lines on it, and sent it out.
Cooks dont spit in your food when they are pissed at you. Instead they take delight in giving you exactly what you ordered. But in the most exagerated way posible. Thats what happened in upstate new york before the cicil war. A customer was complaining that the potatoes au gratin was too soggy. So the cook, George Crum, made up a special batch just for that customer that were sliced so thin and cooked to such a crisp that they couldent be picked up by a fork. Much to his suprise, the customer loved them.
Its reductio ad absurdum. Presenting an example that is so outlandishly over the top that there is no way it could ever be taken seriously. But the risk in using such an argument is that there going to be someone out there who will love it no matter how ridiculous an offering you make to them.
A book version of this trick was published in 1969. Naked Came the Stranger was designed and executed to be the absoulte worse work of lititure to ever see print. Each chapter was writen by a difrent auther who all atempted to one-up each other by writing the crappiest prose imaginable. The only saving grace was that it would be filled with lots of raunchy sex. As expected, it recived high praze from critics who aplauded its bold direction and inovative themes. ….. Theory holds that the Gor novles were writen with the same intent. People were willing to swallow anything just so long as it was anti-feminist.
A few days ago I was lurking in a chatroom when some self proclaimed ‘true slave’ barged in and droped the chalange that anyone who didnt obey her master TOTALY was just a poser wannabe. Well, the other folks in the chatroom didnt take kindly to this. “Oh yeah” they all snapped “well if your master wanted to cut your arm off would you let him?” The intent was to present a situation so extreme that nobody could ever posiably be in suport of it. Demonstrate the absurd by being absurd. But what they didnt realise was that to people who are devoted to their cause, there is no such thing as too extreme. Just like the customer who loved the food that the cook thought no sane person would ever eat, the ‘true slave’ praised eveyones coments and pointed ot that amputation at the whim of the owner is EXACTLY the concept of true slavery that they held in such high regards.